Springer-Lyle News Updates

latest legal news from the law firm of Springer-Lyle

1807 Westminster
Denton, TX 76205

940.387.0404

  • Home
  • About Us
    • Firm Overview
    • Attorney Profiles
  • Areas of Practice
  • Articles and Cases
  • What’s In the News
  • Resources
  • Videos
    • Who is Springer-Lyle?
    • FAQ Videos
      • FAQs on Business Litigation
      • FAQs on Healthcare, Medical & Pharmaceutical Cases
      • FAQs on Personal Injury, Automobile & Trucking Accidents
      • FAQs on Alternative Dispute Resolution
      • FAQs on Probate Cases
  • Contact Us
You are here: Home / Blog Articles / Bar Related / The New “Loser Pays”

The New “Loser Pays”

February 14, 2012 By admin Leave a Comment

A lot of my friends have asked me about the new “loser pays” law and how I expect it to affect litigation in Texas.  For years, Texas and most other states followed the so-called, “American Rule” whereby litigants pay their own attorneys’ fees.  There were exceptions, such as certain statutory provisions that allowed recovery of attorneys fees in breach of contract, declaratory judgments, and other types of lawsuits.  The new law is a departure from our historical approach, and represents a Texas version of the “English Rule,” allowing the prevailing party to recoup attorneys’ fees and litigation costs.

Originally enacted in 2003 and revised significantly last year, the law allows a party to make a settlement offer and trigger a loser-pays situation.  If the judgment ultimately rendered is significantly less favorable to the party who rejected the offer, that party is required to pay the other party’s costs and attorneys’ fees (from the date of the offer forward).  “Significantly less favorable” is defined as less than 80% of an offer rejected by a plaintiff, and more than 120% of an offer rejected by a defendant.
My prediction when the law originated was that it would rarely be used.  I thought this would be especially true in the kind of high-stakes litigation involving most of our firm’s clients.  Sensible attorneys avoid adding to their clients’ litigation costs and avoid taking unnecessary risks. This is especially true when the issues are complex and the potential recovery is enormous.  It bears adding that some of my clients are businesses and insurance companies in litigation against individuals who have no assets from which a judgment could be collected.

My own experience and the reported cases involving the statute seem to support the prediction.  The lawyers in my firm have not been involved in a single case in which in which the new law has been invoked.  Only three appellate courts have written opinions concerning the loser-pays statute—so most of my colleagues share our experience.  Only one of the reported cases involved a recovery over $ 1 Million.  In two of the three cases, (including the multi-million dollar case) litigation expenses and fees were awarded to the Plaintiff, not the defendant, in sharp contrast to the claims of some legislators who supported it as a protection against meritless claims.
In short, the law has just not been invoked much in its eight-plus years of existence, and nothing about the 2011 amendments is likely to change that.  For those interested in learning more, the statute can be found at https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/CP/htm/CP.42.htm#42.004 .   A good history of the legislation is summarized at Tex Parte Blog.

Filed Under: Bar Related, From the Firm Tagged With: Appellate Court, Attorney, Attorney’s Fees, Contract, Denton, Fees, Insurance, Judgment, Lawsuit, Lawyers, Litigation, Loser Pays, Personal Injury, Recovery, Settlement Offer, Texas

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Subscribe by email

Have the latest news from Springer-Lyle
sent to your inbox.

Articles of Interest

Honda Worldwide Recall of Sedans, Minivans, SUVs

By Deepa Seetharaman and Bernie Woodall of Reuters. Honda Motor Co Ltd plans to recall nearly 2 1/2 million vehicles: small SUVs, cars and minivans worldwide. This includes the popular Accord sedan. … [Read More…]

Hip Implant Complaints Increase, While Dangers Are Reviewed

By BARRY MEIER and JANET ROBERTS of the New York Times Published: August 22, 2011 The federal government has received a surge in complaints in recent months about failed hip replacements, suggesting … [Read More…]

Tragedy Brought on by Tainted Fruit

By Moni Basu, CNN William Beach was one of those people who fixated on certain foods. He would eat the same thing voraciously for a few days, and then, when he tired of the same tastes, he moved onto … [Read More…]

No Better Care, Thanks to Tort Reform

Published in The Texas Tribune by guest columnist, Charles M. Silver In 2006, Dr. Howard Marcus wrote that Texas’ 2003 tort reform statute sparked an “amazing turnaround” in which doctors came … [Read More…]

Springer & Lyle, LLP

1807 Westminster
Denton, TX 76205

phone: 940.387.0404
toll-free: 855.387.0404
fax: 940.383.7656

Disclaimer
The contents of this website does not imply legal advise or counsel and does not establish an attorney/client relationship. Please contact us for information on our policies regarding any relationship with clients, potential clients, or non-clients of our firm.

  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

 

 

make a Pament via LawPay

Return To Top of Page

Copyright © 2023 Springer & Lyle, L.L.P. • • • All Rights Reserved

Website Design by The Crouch Group

Log in